
It's a decent time to be a Legion fan these days. I mean, you have two to choose from!
Been going over some Legion forums and checking out sales charts on both current versions of the my favourite future super team. So what do we have?
In
Action Comics right now, we have what I call the Levitz Legion--the 'adult Legion' I remember from the Eighties.
My Legion. Geoff Johns is doing a superb job with this story,giving the entire book a true Legion feel. And it has Dawnstar. Gary Franks does a very, very good Dawnstar. That alone makes this title worth picking up. And the sales seem to reflect this--Action Comics # 861 sold 56,000 copies. Pretty solid. Still,
Buffy the Vampire Slayer outsells it, which I type only because I never envisaged a point in my life where I would do so.
Over in the other Legion--the titular
Legion of Super-Heroes--we finally have a writer there who isn't trying to reinvent the wheel only to make it a more cooler wheel. Jim Shooter may have his detractors, but since I've never had to work for him, I'm not one of them. He is a solid writer, and after the stumbles and disappointments of the WKRP version of this Legion, it's nice to actually feel like I'm reading a proper Legion book again. The sales aren't as great as
Action, coming in around 33,000--but that can be attributed to Johns' star power and the steady core of fans who buy anything with Superman in it. Sadly, it's still the WKRP Legion, but Shooter writes it as if it's the Levitz Legion. I can almost imagine him asking to do his own, proper version, being told 'no', then just doing his best to ignore the whole 'teen rebellion' aspect.
You see, I don't think Waid and Kitson ever really got it. The Legion isn't about irony. It isn't about Ultra Boy banging Triplicate Girl. It's about a super powered team of friends who border at times on the ludicrous, but are all the more awesome for that. Look at Ultra Boy, for example: he's a guy who has all of Superman's powers, but
can only use one at at a time. That's ludicrous--if you take as a base that having all of Superman's powers at all
isn't. And that's why it's awesome.
Same with Stone Boy, one of the worst...I mean...more challenging Substitute Heroes. A guy who can turn into rock, but doesn't do anything after that. Or Arm Fall Off Boy. Or Chlorophyll Kid, who thinks he can talk to plants but can't. That's the Legion. Having Saturn Girl's people lose the ability to speak because they're telepathic isn't. That's just ludicrous, with no fun factor involved.
And that, dear readers, is why the WKRP version of the Legion never failed to gel with me. Mark Waid--who I admire as a writer--tried to hammer the Legion into something it isn't.
For now, we have Geoff Johns and Jim Shooter, who do get it.
Me, I'm just enjoying it while it lasts.